Letter to the Editor - Allison Herrera Padilla
Dear Editor,
I am a tenth grade student at Waltham High School and a participant in the Brandeis Upward Bound Program. Upward Bound is a program that is a great oppor tunity for first generation students who want to go to college. As a part of the larger Brandeis and Waltham community, I am writing about an issue that impacts all of us: segregation in the Waltham public schools based on income, which has result ed in huge disparities in race and funding between schools. This means that students of color in Waltham attend schools with lower funding than their white counter parts. Our students are being discrimi nated against because of their financial status, which also affects their education. Comparing both Kennedy and McDevitt Middle Schools, there is an exterior differ ence as well as an interior difference.
Firstly, our schools are so noticeably different because household incomes drastically segregate kids by ethnicity in Waltham. In Waltham, the neighborhoods with the highest incomes are Pigeon Hill, Piety Corner, Jericho Hill, and others. According to bestneighborhood.org and Waltham’s District Profile, the house holds with the most income are almost all located near Kennedy Middle. These neighborhoods are also where there is a higher white population. Kennedy Mid dle School’s ethnic population is mostly white which is 47.3% of the student body, while the other largest group is Hispanic, at 34.1% of the school population. McDe vitt Middle School, on the other hand, has an average low income as shown in the school as well as the community around the school. The average income that is around the school is mostly low with some average-income neighborhoods as seen in bestneigborhood.org. On the Waltham’s District Profile, McDevitt has a greater Hispanic population, making up 61.9% of the school. Kennedy has almost twice the white population that Mcdevitt does, and about half the amount of Hispanic stu dents. This large white population follows income statistics in the area. These sta tistics as well as income households show why and how these schools are segregated because of income.
Children in Waltham are segregated based on race before they even start school. This results in a gap in opportunities for students. Considering the options between the Kennedy Middle Schools Page of extra curricular activities, we see that KMS has 20 activities which include six sports. Con sidering the financial status of the school the amount of afterschool activities is logi cal on the amount of opportunities for the students. On the Mcdevitt Middle Schools page, there are 16 activities including four sports. Knowing that this school is of lower income, the amount of afterschool activities, especially sports, gives a clear understanding of how both buildings are treated and how they affect our students. Both of these sources show how different both schools are compared to each other, which affects the school’s community, but most importantly, the students.
MMS and KMS aren’t the only schools affected by this segregation. In Spring field, MA in 2010-2011, public schools en rollment had decreased at the same time that Hispanic enrollment increased. These students were low income as well as mi norities in, “intensely segregated schools, indicating that Springfield’s students are segregated by race and class; the share of low-income students in intensely seg regated schools increased from 75.2% in 1999-2000 to 89.9% in 2010-2011” from The Civil Rights Project. Students of color have been in segregated schools for over two de cades. As the numbers of students of color increased in enrollment, white students had started to decrease in public school enrollment. Continuing, not only did par ents and the community around the school stop enrolling in the schools, but buses in Boston started segregating students by color in 1974. There had been many pro tests and Massachusetts passed a Racial Imbalance Act “To address longstanding segregation”. The Act required districts to bus white students to predominantly Black schools and Black students to predomi nantly white schools. This program was met with widespread outrage, and has not done enough to address the problem of ra cial segregation in Massachusetts schools. Waltham is part of the rule, not the exception.
In conclusion, Kennedy Middle School and Mcdevitt Middle School are segregated by income but also as statistics show, by race as well. Our students are affected by this since they are not getting the proper resources they need. Students’ educa tion is most important, and seeing that future generations of incoming students aren’t being treated the same should be changed. Brandeis students should in tend to research public school segregation since most of the students have lived in Waltham. Public school segregation has been a problem since before 1974. Families, community members as well as student bodies should bring light to the situation that has been concealed and reserved for a while.
Respectfully,
Allison Herrera Padilla
Please note All comments are eligible for publication in The Justice.